Is Apple Cider Vinegar Good For You? Let’s Seperate Myths From the Facts

Apple cider vinegar (ACV) has surged in popularity, particularly for its alleged health benefits, which are often discussed online and in various wellness communities. A significant number of Americans have experimented with ACV for health reasons, suggesting a widespread interest in its potential effects.

The primary component of ACV is acetic acid, which results from the fermentation of sugars in apple juice into alcohol, followed by a second fermentation into vinegar. This process is common to all vinegar, but ACV is favored for its palatability compared to more pungent vinegar like white or balsamic. Let’s look at how it affects the body and some common myths around it.

How Apple Cider Vinegar Affects the Body

Understanding how apple cider vinegar interacts with the body requires a look into its basic composition and its physiological impacts. Fundamentally, ACV is created through the fermentation of apple juice into acetic acid, which is responsible for most of its biological activities. This acetic acid isn’t unique to apple cider vinegar; it’s a common component in all vinegars, influencing their tangy taste and potential health effects.

Glycemic Control

One of the more examined effects of ACV is its impact on blood sugar levels. Research indicates that consuming ACV can influence glycemic control. Specifically, when ACV is consumed after a starchy meal, it can slow the gastric emptying rate—the rate at which food exits the stomach and enters the intestines. This slowing down means that starches are converted into sugars at a slower rate, which can prevent a rapid spike in blood sugar. By moderating how quickly sugars are absorbed, the body’s insulin response is also modulated, which is beneficial for managing blood sugar levels, particularly for individuals who are diabetic or pre-diabetic.

Impact on Digestion

The delayed gastric emptying not only helps in controlling blood sugar levels but also affects how long foods stay in the stomach, potentially increasing feelings of fullness. This mechanism is often cited in discussions about ACV’s role in weight management, though scientific evidence supporting significant weight loss through ACV is sparse. Studies show minimal impact on long-term weight loss, with results showing only slight weight reductions that are not sustainable or clinically meaningful.

Dental Health Risks

Beyond digestion, the chemical nature of ACV—as an acid with a pH between 2 and 3—poses risks to dental health. Regular exposure to such acidity can erode dental enamel, the hard outer surface of teeth, making them more susceptible to decay and cavities. This erosion manifests because the acetic acid in ACV can demineralize dental enamel, leading to a roughened surface texture and increased sensitivity.

Impact on Skin and Scalp

On the skin and scalp, ACV’s acidity can disrupt the natural pH, which is crucial for barrier function and microbial balance. While it may reduce dandruff by lowering the pH to a level that inhibits the growth of certain fungi, it can also irritate and burn the scalp if used undiluted. In terms of hair care, while it might help in removing odors and excess oils, its high acidity can lead to scalp irritation, necessitating dilution with water to mitigate potential harm.

Common Myths About Apple Cider Vinegar

Apple cider vinegar is often hailed as a miracle cure-all, but many of the claims surrounding its benefits are based more on folklore than on hard science. Here, we address some prevalent myths about apple cider vinegar and clarify what the research really shows, providing medical and scientific context for each claim.

Myth 1: Apple Cider Vinegar Cures Diabetes

Reality: While some studies suggest that apple cider vinegar may help lower blood sugar levels by slowing the rate at which food leaves the stomach and enters the lower digestive tract, this effect might only be marginal. For instance, a study shows that vinegar may improve insulin sensitivity during a high-carb meal by about 19-34%, yet this does not equate to curing diabetes. Diabetes management involves complex dietary planning, regular monitoring of blood glucose levels, and sometimes medication. Relying on ACV as a treatment can lead to inadequate control of chronic blood glucose levels, posing serious health risks.

Myth 2: Significant Weight Loss

Reality: Claims that ACV can lead to significant weight loss are not backed by robust research. The mechanism where ACV could aid in minor weight loss involves delayed gastric emptying, which potentially helps individuals feel fuller longer, thereby reducing overall calorie intake. However, as noted by WebMD, the effects are so minor that they are unlikely to lead to substantial weight loss. Effective weight management typically requires a combination of dietary changes, increased physical activity, and sometimes behavioral therapy.

Myth 3: Prevents Heart Disease

Reality: There is no direct evidence linking the consumption of apple cider vinegar with the prevention of heart disease. While controlling blood sugar levels can indirectly reduce the risk of heart disease, the effects of ACV on blood sugar are too minor to significantly influence heart disease risks. Heart disease prevention strategies typically involve managing cholesterol levels, blood pressure, and other cardiovascular risk factors through diet, exercise, and medication.

Myth 4: Cures Skin Conditions

Reality: The assertion that ACV can cure acne, eczema, or psoriasis lacks scientific support. The skin’s natural barrier is slightly acidic for protection against pathogens and maintaining moisture. Dr. Bradley Glodny of Park Ave Derm cautions against using acidic substances directly on your skin. “Putting ACV on your skin can cause irritation and rashes,” he says.

Disrupting this pH balance with an acidic product like vinegar can irritate the skin and exacerbate conditions rather than providing a cure. Research on the topical use of ACV for skin conditions is scant, and Glodny recommends treatments that preserve or restore the skin’s natural pH rather than disrupt it.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Bradley Glodny (@dr_bradley_glodny)

Myth 5: Reduces High Blood Pressure

Reality: There is no significant research to support the claim that ACV can reduce high blood pressure. Lifestyle factors such as diet, exercise, and stress management, along with medication, are the proven methods for managing high blood pressure. Reliance on ACV for this purpose could distract from more effective treatments.

Myth 6: Cures Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS)

Reality: The claim that ACV treats PCOS is not substantiated by extensive research. PCOS is a complex endocrine disorder, and its management typically involves addressing insulin resistance, hormonal imbalances, and inflammation through medication, lifestyle changes, and dietary adjustments. The limited studies on ACV and PCOS do not provide strong evidence of its efficacy and are not a replacement for medical treatment.

Bottom Line

Overall, while ACV is sometimes celebrated as a panacea for various health issues, its actual effects on the body are more limited and specific. Its primary active ingredient, acetic acid, can offer some health benefits, particularly related to glycemic control, but it also poses risks such as enamel erosion and digestive slowdowns that may not benefit everyone. As with any remedy, the benefits and drawbacks must be weighed carefully, and it’s important to stay informed about what the science actually says.